Houwelings defends intellectual property

Houweling’s Tomatoes, the greenhouse grower headquartered in Delta, British Columbia, has been successful in defending its intellectual property for UltraClima Semi-Closed Greenhouse patent. It’s a design used in its California and Utah properties. 


The patent was opposed by 11 greenhouse manufacturers. On October 11, 2019, the U.S. Patent Trial and Appeal Board ruled against the lead challenger Van Der Hoeven Horticultural Projects. The decision was based on the fact that Van der Hoeven failed to show that claims in the Ultra-Clima patent were unpatentable.


“It is not our first time defending the patent over the years,” David Bell, chief marketing officer for Houweling’s told The Grower. “The Ultra Clima design is a gold standard and has considerable research and development cost and expertise. It is not technology that is available to others through license which allows recuperation for the significant investment.”


A November 2017 article in Forbes, penned by Stephen Key, underlines some key points about whether patents matter in today’s competitive marketplace. He wrote: “Contrary to popular belief, a patent does not protect your technology from being infringed upon by a competitor. It merely affords you with legal recourse in the event that someone does.”


He warns that if you try to enforce patent rights in courts, plan on spending three to five years. And expect that getting a judgment costs millions of dollars.  He quotes Silicon Valley patent attorney Damon Kali: 


“A patent gives you a seat at the table, both offensively and defensively. That’s it. In other words, a patent gets you some relevance and some leverage. How much relevance and leverage depends on how you play your hand and how deep your pockets are.”





Source: Houweling’s October 30, 2019 news release

If latest news: 
Check if it is latest news (for "Latest News" page)
Publish date: 
Monday, November 4, 2019

Click to leave a comment

For security purposes, please confirm you are not a robot!


Cornell U releases three new apple varieties

Orchardists in New York state and across the U.S. will have access to three new apple varieties:  Cordera, Pink Luster and Firecracker.   

OECD reports unprecedented fall in gross domestic product

The Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development reports a fall of 9.8% in GDP in Q2 of 2020. This is the largest drop ever recorded for the major seven economies. GDP fell most dramatically in the United Kingdom and the least in the United States. Canada’s GDP fell 12%.  

Field practices updated for California leafy greens

More than 50 recommendations have been approved by the California Leafy Greens Marketing Agreement to revise practices in farm water use and field/equipment sanitation. The action comes after 2019 outbreaks of E. coli-contaminated romaine lettuce. 

United Fresh Convention moves to June 2021

The United Fresh Produce Association and Fresh Produce and Floral Council will hold a joint convention and expo June 24-26, 2021 in Los Angeles, California. 


Syngenta Vegetable Seeds offer virtual cucurbit event

The free-to-attend online experience, September 10, aims to connect the vegetable seed industry value chain with exclusive access to Syngenta innovations and experts.